Saturday, August 1, 2009

Finally, My Answer to Islam, a High School Senior

My attempt at learning Arabic has put me in contact with many new friends, especially at the high school where I avail myself as a reserve teacher. At the close of the 09' semester, a student—a senior, a bright girl, a beautiful young lady full of life—asked me a challenging question. Her name is Islam. Islam asked me: Do you favor Israel or Hamas in the current Palestinian-Israeli conflict?

Wow, now I was on the spot! I valued my student-teacher relationship with Islam and I didn’t want to confuse that relationship with matters related to current world tensions. Nevertheless, I wanted to honor her question with an honest response. I asked her, "Can I think about my response and get back to you?" She smiled and graceously ‘cut me some slack’, as the saying goes.

Well, I didn’t get back to her for time and circumstances snatched away the moment. And I definitely did not intend to “moon-walk” on the question, as the Michael Jackson dance step pictures; God rest his soul. So, I will answer Islam’s question now -- by the way, I knew of Islam’s positive bent toward Hamas and her family’s bias. So, what can I say? I will say this to Islam…

We are a world saturated with media. That media is in the business of manipulating minds, not according to reality, but according to political opinion—that is their unashamed journalistic aim. Add to that that the heritage old men, with old hatreds, passing on their hatred to their children—it is a reprisal generation and we are making our kids think like us. This is a recipe that perpetuates that hatred, with little hope of change from what the media delivers.

This generation can do better. I believe it can. But that “better” will require some bold and courageous choices. And, I don’t think that such bold and courageous choices will happen among my generation. It will be, if at all, among those graduating high school seniors like Islam.

We need our young people to think anew and take charge of something new. That “something new” must cut a path, not in the direction of a heritage of hate, but in the direction of responsible coexistence. Here is the reality of the matter…

Anti-Semitism is an ugly phenomenon that has engendered many atrocities against the Jews over many centuries in Europe. It needed to be addressed. And it was; and it is. But anti-Semitism is a reflection of larger attitudes. Today, the world may be unconsciously replacing anti-Semitism with a different kind of racial intolerance—anti-Arabism. There will be others. But this new kind of racial intolerance passes on new old hatreds, just in a different package. I will explain my thinking in the words of the New York Times.

In an editorial on March 30, 2002, Yossi Berlin, a former member in Barak’s cabinet in Israel, wrote,

The Israeli war against the terrorist infrastructure will give birth to more
terrorists because the terrorist infrastructure lies will give birth to more
terrorists because the terrorist infrastructure lies within people’s hearts. It
can be uprooted only if there I s hope for a different kind of life in the
Middle East.

My question is, is this generation, Islam’s generation, ready to take on such challenge? That is, the challenge of changing future hearts and breaking the culture of old hatreds? If she is not; if she is committed to merely receiving the hatreds the generation before her, than I fear we have little hope.

So, I can ask this question: How bold and how courageous will Islam be? And now the better question: With what values and moral soul will Islam carry the new generation with her? I am going to work on that question for my next blog.

No comments: